Who Wins? This post might contain affiliate links for which we may make a small commission at no extra cost to you should you make a purchase. I am familiar with the Shimano hierarchy, and know that 105 is respectable stuff that a lot of weekend warriors race on. Cyclinghacks.com also participates, and occasionally earns a commission, from linking to additional affiliate sites. 105 as it is 11 speed you could upgrade part by part to Ultegra, or even Dura-Ace. In that time I’ve wanted to make cycling jargon and marketing easier to cut through to help people get the bike of their dreams. Both groups can be built with cable-actuated brakes, or Shimano’s new road-specific hydraulic disc brakes. 105 is only available in a double. The Tiagra short cage will get you up to a 30t cog. You can use these brakes on frames and forks with the older post-mount interface using the appropriate adapter bracket. Wie een nieuwe racefiets koopt moet naast de fiets zelf ook een keuze maken in de groepset die erop mag. Tiagra offers terrific braking and shifting compared to its predecessors, but it’s only a better choice if you need a triple crankset or have a flat handlebar. Road riders are very particular about the function and feel of their drivetrain, braking, and shifting. Shimano Tiagra groep. Jak NIE upgrade'ować roweru - Shimano 105 5800 a Tiagra 4500. Older hubs do not have enough space for the slighter wider cassette and are not at all compatible. Quale sceglieresti? You can build a Tiagra 10-speed group onto a bike with a drop handlebar or flat handlebar with the appropriate brake levers and shifters. Le groupe Tiagra 2016 a vraiment l'air très bien. If you’re upgrading your current bike, but sure to check if your rear hub can handle an 11-speed cassette. Apparu en juin 2015, le Shimano Tiagra (séries 47000) adopte le même style esthétique que le 105, l'Ultegra ou le Dura-Ace, grâce à l'arrivée d'un pédalier à quatre branches. € 16 99. Both use Shimano’s 4-bolt, 110 mm bolt circle diameter spider and chainrings, trickle-down technology of premium Dura Ace and Ultegra level components. They also use a new pad design that is pretty grippy regardless of the conditions that you’re riding in. This makes choosing 105 11-speed hydraulic a no-brainer for people with smaller hands who struggle to shift and brake on a bike with bigger controls. The 11-speed drivetrain is the main attraction to this tier. The brakes, the 105 brakes are so good. Gravel adventures and cyclocross racing might be better served with the 48/34 option. Given the choice between the two groups as an upgrade to your current bike or when picking a new bike, which one should you choose? When I’m not writing about bikes, I can be seen out bikepacking on single speed bikes or teaching kids how to ride. As an added bonus, 105 components are going to shave a few grams off your bike. The design is a symmetrical design which allows more control and power over your braking. De nieuwe SHIMANO TIAGRA FC-4700-crank brengt gewicht en efficiëntie met elkaar in evenwicht zonder op onbuigzaamheid in te boeten. Let’s focus on the middle of that lineup, Tiagra’s main attraction is the group’s versatility. RS500 is about on par with Tiagra. The Tiagra line is considered one step below 105 because 105 is a tad lighter has smoother operation. Vergelijk product. Shimano Has Six Separate Groups; They Include Shimano Tiagra And Shimano 105. If you fancy slowly making your bike a higher spec model, you would be better starting with 105 and working from there. There is though the ability with Tiagra to get a front shifter which will allow you to use a triple chainring at the front. €800. Shimano Tiagra. Tiagra has a far wider range of gears than the 105 group, including double- and triple chainring arrangements. Prijsdaling: €4,20. Latest 105 and Tiagra iterations at this moment are 4700 and 5800. As you’d expect to compare like for like, the 105 chainset is lighter, much lighter. New 10-speed TIAGRA provides serious entry-level riding performance with cascaded technology from top-tier lines. Let’s focus on the middle of that lineup, 105 and Tiagra. The 105 derailleur is 11 speed and can take a large chainring up to 53 teeth. The 105 shifters achieved this in a more compact package, making the Tiagra shifters look bulbous in comparison. When we talk about weight, there is less than a 20g difference between 105 shifters and Tiagra shifters. Main Difference Between Shimano 105 vs Tiagra The 11-speed genie is out of the lamp, and she’s not going back in. Indien je op zoek bent naar een goed functionerend systeem en je slechts over een beperkt budget beschikt, zal je na een snel rekensommetje snel inzien dat je met de aankoop van het Shinamo Tiagra systeem een goede zaak doet. Ask your favorite local bike mechanic for guidance if you’re not sure. Prijs € 29,95 Is it worth saving some money to get Tiagra or are you better off spending the extra for 105? Tiagra and 105 shifters both feature stealthy under-the-bartape cable routing for an uncluttered handlebar. Shimano Tiagra BB-RS500 Bottom Bracket BSA. A groupset is a group of parts that are all made to the same quality. A Shimano 105 R7000 groupset is nominally £596. Like Ultegra, the new R7000 105 derailleurs has taken on some of the features of Shimano’s mountain bike derailleurs. En dat is vooral bij wat uitdagender terrein wel handig. Grandado.com. Both the 105 and Tiagra chainsets carry on Shimano’s love of aluminum cranks arms and a super-strong steel spindle. That means you’ll get a maximum of 22 gears with 105 but a maximum of 30 gears with Tiagra. The Tiagra line is considered one step below 105 because 105 is a tad lighter has smoother operation. Shimano CN-HG53 Tiagra 9-Speed Ketting. Shimano Tiagra zie je veel terug op de wat duurdere racefietsen uit het middensegment. Shimano 105 RD-5700 Derailleurwieltjes . Nous sommes habitués aux cassettes très étagées. Some riders preferred the smoothness they attributed to the exposed, inward-facing shift cable routing of older 9-speed Ultergra shifters (a step up the component group ladder). 105 still comes out on top for the smoother shifting mechanism baked into the controls. Share these hacks with your friends. If you’re in the market for new wheels as well, be sure to pick one that is 11-speed compatible. The next difference is that the Tiagra brakes will work well up to a 28mm wide tire. In de tanden zitten holle ruimtes verwerkt volgens de HyperGilde technologie, zodat het gewicht van de cassette laag gehouden wordt. Hij wordt aangeboden in 52-36-, 50-34T- en (nieuwe) 48-34T-kettingbladopties en crankarmlengtes van 165, 170, 172,5 en 175 mm. As you’d expect to compare like for like, the 105 chainset is lighter, much lighter. Méér info Shimano 105 5800 . Tiagra’s main attraction is the group’s versatility. 10 Best Mountain Bikes Under $2,000 [2020], The Tiagra features a 10-speed system, whereas the 105 is 11-speed system, The 105 disc brakes are more streamlined compared to the Tiagra versions, THe 105 is more customizable and you can upgrade components easier, whereas the Tiagra is a more limited all-or-nothing groupset. Let’s take a closer look. The other has: Shimano 105 shifters, brakes, front and rear Derailleurs, cassette and chain … Dit model is voornamelijk geschikt voor racefietsen en te combineren met andere 10-Speed onderdelen van Shimano. September 2018 edited September 2018 in Road buying advice. There will be a weight penalty for the extra front chainring. Let us look at the parts within the groupsets. There are a few reasons for this. There's also a slight weight difference, but I doubt most riders would notice it. Compared to the Tiagra model, it has better pads and a more sophisticated dual-pivot caliper design. As we said the Tiagra version is also available in a triple, but the 105 chainset goes down to 160mm in length for those of us that are a bit shorter. It will also be a little while longer before 11 speed becomes obsolete. Both Tiagra and 105 use a sleek road-specific flat mount brake caliper that you’ll find on most modern road bikes. The use of Shadow technology helps to reduce the chance of damage to your rear derailleur, it’ll help to keep your shifting stabilized, and it also makes the rear derailleur look a little more compact. Tiagra 4700 is the latest groupset from Shimano to get a makeover, and in doing so it has made Tiagra the best it's ever been. When compared to Tiagra, we’ll again be swayed towards 105. 105 components have had this routing for a few generations, but Tiagra recently received this trickle-down feature. Let us make a short detour before we get to the nitty-gritty discussion of Shimano Tiagra vs. 105 and cover the basics. The 105 and Tiagra dual-pivot brakes are where things get interesting. For all-around road riding, the “compact” 50/34 chainring tooth option or “standard” 53/39 combo would be best. Is Shimano 105 worth a $250 premium over Tiagra? Shimano’s current third- and fourth-tier road groups are very similar in features and appearance, but appearances can be deceiving. The recommended retail price of a complete Shimano Tiagra groupset (chainset, shifters, derailleurs, chain, cassette, brakes, bottom bracket) is £500 or £450, depending which retailer you choose to believe. FSA stuff is actually decent, but it's definitely a step down from the Shimano part. With all the top tier Shimano groups being 11-speed you’ll find it easy to upgrade to them and this should help to make it easier to find parts in the future. € 19 99. Shimano Tiagra heeft 2x10 versnellingen en is daardoor niet compatibel met 105 onderdelen, die 11-speed zijn. I'd figure you would be more concerned about color mismatch. Given how light Shimano can make these, there are no real reasons to expect them to stop soon. 38% KORTING. Purists who opt for the clean simplicity of road caliper brakes will appreciate the refinements made to the 105 rim brake caliper. The 4-arm spider across all road and mountain groupsets was a move to make a wider range of chainring sizes fit on all cranks, including “standard” race-oriented 53/39 combo, conventional “compact” 50/34 combo, and “adventure” 48/34 on Tiagra. Test i porównanie. Vergeleken met de duurdere groepen gaat het schakelen iets minder snel en zijn de onderdelen wat aan de zware kant. 12 Week Cycling Training Plan for Beginners, 4 Week Climbing Supercharge – Hill Climbing Training Program, How to Choose the Best Road Bike Components. Both the 105 and Tiagra chainsets carry on Shimano’s love of aluminum cranks arms and a super-strong steel spindle. Every additional cog in a drivetrain adds an option to spin more efficiently. The new 105 brakes are based on the Ultegra and Dura-Ace SLR-EV Dual Pivot design. The 105 brakes are slightly longer than they were before and this allows you the prospect of running up to 30mm wide tires. When people are buying a new road bike, one of the first questions they ask is, “What is the difference between Shimano 105 and Tiagra.”. In their long cage variations they will both get you up to a 34t, and if you frequent internet forums, you’ll find people have managed to take the 105 version well beyond that. Shimano Tiagra 105 et dérailleurs, à la fois avant et arrière, font partie d'un groupset de composants qui comprend moyeux, manivelles, leviers, poignées, freins et d'autres parties de la chaîne de traction. There is 1 quick and simple answer to that, and that is that Shimano 105 is a 11-speed groupset and Toagra is a 10-speed groupset. Shimano Tiagra – een degelijk systeem voor middelgrote budgetten. One has: Tiagra rear Derailleur, 2200 triple front Derailleur, Shimano 8 speed cassette, and Sora shifters with a carbon+AL seatpost. we respect your privacy and take protecting it seriously. Il gruppo Shimano 105 è il gruppo più venduto al mondo mentre il gruppo Shimano Tiagra è tra i più economici. ... € 9 99. The price difference between the two is not staggering, so either group might check all the boxes for your needs. Like what you see? One of the things you can’t do with Tiagra is upgrading part by part to 105. Shimano’s latest generation of buttery smooth cables and housing seem to have eliminated those problems. Het is lastig kiezen tussen Shimano groepsets, en dan vooral tussen de populaire Shimano Tiagra, Shimano 105 en Shimano Ultegra groepen. Even more amazing, 105 shifters for hydraulic brakes come in standard and small sizes to fit smaller hands. Shimano Tiagra 4600 or 105 5700. ayjaycee Posts: 1,333. € 39 99. The “old” 10-speed might save a few bucks or offer a range of gears that you need. Both feature nickel-plated steel for the cogs but the 105 version uses a light aluminum spider and lock ring, and that is all there is to say about it. In our article about Ultegra versus 105, we were swayed toward 105 because of its cost savings over Ultegra. It is a more budget-friendly choice for any one building a bike from scratch or upgrading a bike with dated parts. The main differences between the Shimano 105 and Tiagra are: The 105 groupset is top of line, with 11-speed gears, a more streamlined design, and the ability to upgrade and customize each compenent (versus an all or nothing groupset). The question though is which groupset should you pick, should you pick Shimano 105 or Ultegra? € 63,99 . , which one should you choose? Je me pose la même question. The other difference is that the Tiagra is 10speed and can take a large chainring up to 52 teeth. I recently had my old bike stolen and decided that I had an opportunity to upgrade. Je kunt hier een grotere cassette monteren tot wel 10 kransjes. The 105 rear derailleurs of yore used to look pretty much like the Tiagra one, now that can’t be said to be the case. You can also choose cable-actuated or hydraulic brakes. There is no flat-bar option, nor a triple-ring crankset in the 105 line. Best Cycling Gloves for 2020: Protect Your Mitts! € 14 99. But 105 has its limitations, and not everyone is counting grams and fractions of a second. This gives riders more choices using a single design and presumably makes the manufacturing process easier for Shimano. The collection of components that are designed to be used together is called a group, groupset, or “gruppo” if the movie Breaking Away did not sully your your love of Italian cycling affectations. Shimano 105 and Ultegra are 2 of the most often picked groupsets by road cyclists. As we’ve already mentioned, the 105 shifters will allow you to shift the rear chain around 11 cogs. But is there more to this difference than just the speed of the groupset? Vergelijk product. Subscribe to our mailing list and get interesting stuff and updates to your email inbox. Op zoek naar artikelen van Shimano Tiagra? On its own, it's not quite as good as the more expensive 105, but if you're buying a new bike with Tiagra 4700, you won't be disappointed. The price difference between the two is not staggering, so either group might check all the boxes for your needs. You’ll then find 10-speed parts will be harder to find, but 11-speed should still be easily sourced. But 105 has its limitations, and not everyone is counting grams and fractions of a second. That doesn’t mean you should save money here, as the 105 brakes offer a few advantages over the Tiagra brakes. Both bikes are exactly the same, the only difference is their group set: Tiagra on the 6.0 and 105 on the 7.0. I've also seen a few 105 bikes going for the "non-group" Shimano RS500 crankset instead of the 105 crankset. The 105 is lighter, and it does deliver crisper gear changes. Eventually, Tiagra will go 11-speed. Fietsen afgemonteerd met Shimano Tiagra zijn te koop vanaf ca. The collection of components that are designed to be used together is called a group, groupset, or “. Both have same crankset design, so I don't see why left crankarm wouldn't be compatible. But what’s the best group? They work faultlessly, and they provide a lot more stopping power than the Tiagra ones. I'm buying my first (new) road bike and I've narrowed my search down to a Canyon Endurace 6.0 or a Canyon Endurace 7.0. Bicycles are typically manufactured using all the parts from a common groupset, however, components such as derailleurs can be purchased individually to swap out or upgrade bicycle performance. The hydraulic calipers from both groups are similar and use interchangeable pads. I’ve spent way more time in the bike trade than anyone should reasonably want to. Road riders are very particular about the function and feel of their drivetrain, braking, and shifting. De Shimano Tiagra CS-HG5000 cassette is een uitstekende keuze in het assortiment van 10-Speed cassettes. There is some room for mixing components from various groups, but many of the components only work within their tier. You can build a, Both groups can be built with cable-actuated brakes, or Shimano’s new road-specific, Given the choice between the two groups as an. Most likely, hydraulic disc brakes will dominate but road bikes in a few years as well. Shimano 105 5800 / Tiagra 4700 Road transmissiekabelset, OPTISLICK gecoat, binnenkant oranje-20%. Cycling Hacks is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com. I would go with mostly 105 components for the smoothest shifting and the benefits of 11-speed gears. Son seul défaut est de proposer seulement 10 vitesses contre 11 pour le 105.Moi qui vient aussi du VTT, je me dis que ce n'est pas très grave. Voorderailleur Shimano Tiagra 10sp Triple FD-4603 Aanlas. Going 11-speed will do more to “future-proof” your drivetrain. Seasoned riders will remember the limits of 6-speed freewheels from “back in the day,” fighting hard to cope with the narrow range and drastic change in effort and RPMs needed between jumps. The Shimano road groupset is then laid out in a hierarchy, starting from the top it is: If you search about you’ll find that a Tiagra groupset also works out around $100 cheaper than a 105 groupset. Vergelijk product. Je roule encore en 9V en 11-34. The Difference Between Shimano 105 and Tiagra, Endurance vs Race Bike: How they Compare & Which One …, Zwift Review: What you need to know about Zwift, Shimano GRX vs 105: Which Groupset Should You Choose. Riders who can tell when they are pedaling optimum cadence will appreciate that they have more subtle, but essential, gear in their arsenal to push them ahead (or at least keep up) with the pack. Is it worth the upgrade to 105 or does Tiagra fit the bill? Vanaf de Shimano Tiagra groep kom je bij de groepsets voor de wat meer geoefende wielrenners. Shimano TIAGRA 4600 10 speed fiets Kettingblad bcd 130 52 T 39 T Originele Kroon - 39t. The Shimano Tiagra and the Shimano 105 remain among the leading candidates for high-investment road bike gear. SHIMANO TIAGRA 4700 SERIES | SHIMANO BIKE COMPONENT CORPORATE €16,79. Il n'a donc plus grand-chose à leur envier, si ce n'est la cassette 11 vitesses, puisque ce Tiagra reste en 10 vitesses… Let’s take a closer look. 4. There’s no denying the versatility and all-weather stopping power of Shimano’s renowned hydraulic braking technology that have dominated the mountain bike market for many years. I'm looking at two bikes right now. Given how light Shimano can make these, there are no real reasons to expect them to stop soon. En er is enorm veel keuze in verschillende soorten Shimano groepsets voor racefietsen. Shimano Tiagra. You’ll also find that it is capable of reaching 30t cogs on your cassette in its short cage version. Both have aluminum frames with carbon forks. Shimano 105 R7000 components are oriented to conventional road riding, with speed and performance over versatility and thrift. Shimano has a reputation for building superb groups with technology that trickles down from one elite generation of Dura Ace components, down through Ultegra, 105 [one oh five], Tiagra, Sora, and the humble Claris line.